(Another) Way Too Early Roster Prediction

DuJuan Harris has some competition for his roster spot. Does he make it?

DuJuan Harris has some competition for his roster spot. Does he make it?

By Jon Meerdink

With one preseason game in the books, at least a few of the names on the Packers roster are starting to move, but not all of them. Unfortunately, some position groups are becoming even more muddled than they were to begin with. Let’s take another quick look at where the roster could  stand  just over three weeks from the first roster cutdown.

Quarterbacks (3)
Aaron Rodgers
Scott Tolzien
Matt Flynn

Analysis: Tolzien moves slightly ahead of Flynn with a strong showing in Saturday’s preseason game, but not by much. His arm strength was on display, while Flynn struggled against the wet conditions. That said, I still think the Packers could carry three quarterbacks. There’s enough breathing room elsewhere on the roster to make it a possibility.

Running backs/fullbacks (4)
Eddie Lacy
James Starks
DuJuan Harris
John Kuhn

Analysis: I’m backing off the first prediction of four backs on the roster, but at least one other position group could make four running backs a possibility. If there is a fourth running back, it’d be Rajion Neal, not LaDarius Perkins, at this point. Ina Liaina is big and runs angry, but he’s not quite enough to unseat John Kuhn, at least not this year.

Tight End (4)
Richard Rodgers

Andrew Quarless
Brandon Bostick
Ryan Taylor

Analysis: The first three are locks, and Ryan Taylor wins the fourth job by default. Jake Stoneburner didn’t flash in the preseason game, Justin Perillo is just a guy, and Colt Lyerla is hurt. Richard Rodgers was just as advertised in the first preseason game, so he retains his top spot.

Wide Receiver (5)
Jordy Nelson
Randall Cobb
Jarrett Boykin
Davante Adams
Jeff Janis

Analysis: Three veterans and a draft pick all have their spots locked up. I think the fifth spot could go to Jeff Janis by default, simply because nobody else has been that impressive. It’s not for lack of opportunities either. Chris Harper had two big drops (on top of two big catches, to be fair) and Kevin Dorsey was just average on Saturday.

Offensive Line (8)
David Bakhtiari
Josh Sitton
J.C. Tretter
T.J. Lang
Bryan Bulaga
Derek Sherrod
Lane Taylor
Corey Linsley

Analysis: Don Barclay‘s injury forces another addition to the o-line group. The Packers now have to keep a backup at both guard and tackle to make up for Barclay’s absence. Lane Taylor is the first guy up at this point, while Sherrod gains a little job security in Barclay’s absence. Corey Linsley sticks around as a backup center.

Defensive Line (6)
B.J. Raji
Mike Daniels
Datone Jones
Josh Boyd
Khyri Thornton
Mike Pennel

Analysis: Not a lot of mystery here. The three big guns (Raji, Daniels, Jones) are locked in. Boyd and Thornton are safe. The sixth spot is the only question mark, and the wide-bodied Mike Pennel occupied the most snaps on Saturday. It feels like it’s his job to lose. Flexibility at linebacker (Peppers, Neal, Perry) give the Packers the option of carrying only a few defensive linemen.

Linebackers (10)
Clay Matthews
Julius Peppers
A.J. Hawk
Brad Jones
Mike Neal
Nick Perry
Jamari Lattimore
Carl Bradford
Nate Palmer
Sam Barrington

Analysis: The defense makes up some ground on the defensive line with the new elephant position. It seemed like a couple undrafted free agents might be pushing for playing time at inside linebacker, but Jake Doughty’s injury throws that into question. If Carl Bradford ever moves inside, it could open up a spot for an undrafted rookie at outside linebacker. Jayrone Elliot is a possibility.

Cornerback (6)
Sam Shields
Tramon Williams
Casey Hayward
Davon House
Jarrett Bush
Jumal Rolle

Analysis: It’s possible I could be suffering from some recency bias, but man was it nice to see Jumal Rolle making a couple plays on Saturday. Micah Hyde‘s hybrid skills does make it possible that only five cornerbacks could make the final roster, but for now, let’s stick with six.

Safety (4)
Micah Hyde

Morgan Burnett
Ha Ha Clinton-Dix
Sean Richardson

Analysis: Nothing too shocking here. Sean Richardson continues his stellar camp, while Hyde, Burnett, and Clinton-Dix all had their spots locked up from day one. If the Packers choose to go with five cornerbacks, the Chris Banjo could fill an extra safety spot here, or that roster spot could potentially end up being filled by a running back.

Specialists (3)
Mason Crosby
Tim Masthay
Brett Goode

Analysis: No competition means no doubt here. These three roster spots are safe.

Conclusion: Injuries have forced a couple small shifts, but overall the roster seems surprisingly set. We could still seem a couple surprising shifts at running back, or perhaps even quarterback.

Tagged , , , ,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 598 other followers

%d bloggers like this: